Smokers go on sale several times a year, and Amazon has cut them around Thanksgiving before. Last year the GE Profile Smart Indoor Smoker fell to about $424 over Thanksgiving weekend, against $699 now, and the Masterbuilt 30-inch electric reached $200 the week before. As we checked in late October, though, none of the eight Picks below was cheaper than its recent average.
We compared every price with what each smoker sold for on Amazon over the past 90 days and its lowest price of the past year, not its list price. Each Pick says what a real deal would look like.
Our picks at a glance
8 deals1.A pellet smoker that also sears like a grill, with strong smoke at low heat. Not discounted yet; it sold for about $875 last December.
2.The easiest way to start: set a temperature, feed chips from the side, walk away. Near its usual price; it was $200 last November.
3.The charcoal smoker testers keep returning to: steady heat for hours and built to last. It has held at $419 all year.
4.The cheapest smoker we would buy: a charcoal bullet that turns out a real smoke ring. At its usual price; it hit $148 in February.
5.Charcoal flavor with a thermostat, an app and searing heat on one cooker. Slightly above its usual price; it was $649 in late May.
6.The small-space pick: an electric grill with a pellet smoke box, sized for a balcony. Above its usual price; it was about $400 in May.
7.The Traeger to buy if price is no object: heavy smoke at low temperatures and Traeger's app. Above its usual price; it was $1,200 in July.
8.The only smoker here for an apartment kitchen: real pellet smoke, filtered so the room stays clear. It was about $424 last Thanksgiving weekend.
Our picks
#1Best overall
Weber Searwood 600 Pellet Smoker Grill
by Weber
The Searwood 600 is the smoker we would buy if we could only own one outdoor cooker. Smoked BBQ Source named it the best pellet grill it has tested in its October update, and AmazingRibs gave it a Platinum Medal for smoke flavor that held up from low-and-slow cooks to searing heat. That combination is why it beat the Traeger Woodridge Pro, which reviewers found less smoky and weaker at searing.
Skip it if you want charcoal flavor or have less than $500 to spend; the Weber Smokey Mountain and Cuisinart below cover those.
At $999 it costs about $18 more than its 90-day average, so this is not a deal yet. It sold for about $875 in early December last year, and that is the price we would wait for.
Pros
- +Strong smoke flavor from low-and-slow to high heat
- +Sears across nearly the whole grate
- +Controller recovers quickly after the lid opens
- +Adjustable smoke setting
- +Easy grease and ash cleanup
Cons
- −Ran about 15°F under its set temperature in AmazingRibs testing
- −Small side shelf, and the front shelf costs extra
- Fuel
- Wood pellets
- Heat control
- Digital thermostat
- App control
- Yes
- Best for
- Smoking and searing
Price checked on Amazon Oct 27, 2026, 12:17 PM ET.
#2
Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Smoker (MB20071117)
by Masterbuilt
This is the simplest way to start smoking meat. You plug it in, set a temperature and feed wood chips through the side loader without opening the door, so heat and smoke stay inside. Smoked BBQ Source names Masterbuilt's digital line its best electric smoker, and with more than 11,000 Amazon ratings it is the most-reviewed smoker on this list by a wide margin.
The 275°F ceiling means no crisp chicken skin and a softer bark than charcoal gives. Owners also report that the built-in temperature readout can drift, so a separate probe thermometer is worth the small extra cost.
Ignore the list price on the card; this smoker sells for about a third of it. At about $237 it sits roughly $13 above its 90-day average, and it reached $200 a week before Thanksgiving last year.
Pros
- +Side loader adds wood chips without opening the door
- +Well insulated, so temperatures hold steady
- +710 sq in of rack space
- +Can cold smoke with an add-on kit
Cons
- −Tops out at 275°F, too low for crisp poultry skin
- −Thin smoke below about 200°F
- −No meat probe included
- −Small chip tray needs refilling on long cooks
- Fuel
- Electric with wood chips
- Heat control
- Digital thermostat
- App control
- No
- Best for
- First-time smokers
Price checked on Amazon Oct 27, 2026, 12:17 PM ET.
#3
Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18-inch
by Weber
The Smokey Mountain is the charcoal smoker reviewers keep coming back to. Smoked BBQ Source rates the 18-inch model its best charcoal smoker and its best smoker for beginners, and America's Test Kitchen picked the 22-inch version as its winner after it ran about 10 hours on a load. It suits anyone who wants real charcoal bark and smoke and is happy to learn the vents over a few cooks.
The access door leaks out of the box, which an inexpensive gasket fixes. If you cook whole briskets, the 22-inch gives you the room the 18-inch lacks.
Weber barely discounts this one. It has sold for $419 for the past year, so buy it on merit and treat any Black Friday cut as a bonus.
Pros
- +Holds a steady temperature for hours on one load
- +Durable enamel coating
- +Deep smoke flavor and bark
- +Small footprint for its capacity
Cons
- −Access door leaks until you fit a gasket
- −Vents take practice to control
- −Adding charcoal and refilling the water pan are awkward
- −Tight for a whole packer brisket
- Fuel
- Charcoal and wood
- Heat control
- Manual vents
- App control
- No
- Best for
- Charcoal flavor
Price checked on Amazon Oct 27, 2026, 12:17 PM ET.
#4Best budget
Cuisinart COS-118 18-inch Vertical Charcoal Smoker
by Cuisinart
The COS-118 is the cheapest smoker we would recommend. Reviewed named it its Best Value smoker after a brisket came out with a good smoke ring, and it uses the same bullet design as the Weber Smokey Mountain for about half the price. It suits a first smoker for someone not yet sure how often they will use it.
The trade-offs show on long cooks: the steel is thinner than Weber's, the cooker is a little shallower, and you will need to add charcoal partway through. Some owners struggled to get it up to temperature until they learned the vents.
At about $210 it costs a couple of dollars more than its 90-day average. It dropped to $148 in February, so a price closer to $150 is what a real deal would look like.
Pros
- +Produces a proper smoke ring on brisket
- +Gallon-size water pan
- +Two 18-inch cooking grates
- +Quick, simple setup
Cons
- −Thinner steel than the Weber Smokey Mountain
- −Little room between the bottom rack and the water bowl
- −Hard to get hot until you learn the vents
- −Needs more charcoal partway through long cooks
- Fuel
- Charcoal and wood
- Heat control
- Manual vents
- App control
- No
- Best for
- Tight budgets
Price checked on Amazon Oct 27, 2026, 12:17 PM ET.
#5
Masterbuilt Gravity Series 600 (MB20041023)
by Masterbuilt
The Gravity Series 600 is for people who want charcoal flavor without tending a fire. A hopper feeds charcoal down to a fan-controlled firebox, so you set a temperature on the controller or the app and it holds it, then you can turn it up to sear. Smoked BBQ Source calls it the best of both worlds on its beginner list.
We kept it on the list despite an Amazon rating well below the rest, built on fewer than 50 reviews, because no other Pick does this job and testers rate the design. The complaints are real, though: owners report fan and controller failures, and the warranty is one year. The Barbecue Lab took 90 to 120 minutes to build the larger Gravity 800, so plan an afternoon for this one too.
At $749 it costs about $14 more than its 90-day average. It sold for $649 in late May.
Pros
- +Charcoal flavor with set-and-forget temperature control
- +Gets hot enough for a hard sear
- +Easy ash cleanup
- +WiFi app for checking temperatures
Cons
- −Owner reports of fan and controller failures
- −One-year warranty
- −Hopper design wastes some charcoal
- −Long assembly
- Fuel
- Charcoal and wood
- Heat control
- Digital thermostat
- App control
- Yes
- Best for
- Charcoal with a thermostat
Price checked on Amazon Oct 27, 2026, 12:17 PM ET.
#6
Ninja Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL Grill & Smoker (OG951)
by Ninja
This is the Pick for a balcony or a small patio. The Woodfire Pro Connect Premium XL is an electric grill with a small box that burns wood pellets for flavor, not heat, so it needs only an outlet. TechRadar found its smoked food as good as the original Woodfire's and the app reliable, and Reviewed got strong smoke flavor on wings. The listing we track is the blue finish.
Do not expect the smoke of a real smoker. Smoked BBQ Source found the flavor mild, AmazingRibs got little smoke ring from the original Woodfire, and the grill area feeds about four to six people. Anyone with a yard and a bigger crowd should look at the Searwood 600 instead.
At about $500 it costs $24 more than its 90-day average. It sold for about $400 in mid-May.
Pros
- +Plugs into an outlet, with no gas or charcoal
- +Grills, smokes and air fries in one unit
- +Compact enough for a balcony or small patio
- +App and built-in thermometers track the cook
Cons
- −Milder smoke flavor than a dedicated smoker
- −About 180 sq in of grill space, tight for more than six people
- −Short power cord that does not detach
- Fuel
- Electric with wood pellets
- Heat control
- Digital thermostat
- App control
- Yes
- Best for
- Balconies and small patios
Price checked on Amazon Oct 27, 2026, 12:17 PM ET.
#7Best premium
Traeger Ironwood Pellet Grill & Smoker (616 sq in)
by Traeger
The Ironwood is the Traeger we would choose if price were no limit. Smoked BBQ Source calls it the sweet spot of Traeger's range, and Reviewed's pick for best pellet grill is its larger sibling, the Ironwood XL. Testers got brisket with a good smoke ring and plenty of smoke at low temperatures, and the Super Smoke mode helps on shorter cooks.
It is slow to reach searing heat, so if you want one cooker for brisket and steaks, the Searwood 600 does more for less. Buy the Ironwood for the smoke, Traeger's app and its accessory range.
At about $1,690 it costs around $67 more than its 90-day average and nearly $500 more than its mid-July low of about $1,200. We would not buy it at this price.
Pros
- +Heavy smoke at low temperatures
- +Consistent temperatures over long cooks
- +Super Smoke mode for shorter cooks
- +Traeger's WiFi app and accessory range
Cons
- −Slow to reach high searing temperatures
- −Needs an outdoor outlet and a steady supply of pellets
- Fuel
- Wood pellets
- Heat control
- Digital thermostat
- App control
- Yes
- Best for
- Maximum pellet smoke
Price checked on Amazon Oct 27, 2026, 12:17 PM ET.
#8
GE Profile Smart Indoor Smoker (P9SBAAS6VBB)
by GE Profile
The GE Profile is the only smoker here you can run in an apartment kitchen. It burns a small charge of wood pellets and filters the smoke before it leaves the unit. Reviewed named it its Best Indoor smoker for smoky, tender brisket and ribs with almost no smoke in the room, and CNN Underscored agreed it delivers real smoke flavor indoors.
Engadget found the flavor less intense than an outdoor smoker's and had to flip and rotate food during cooks. Reviewers also found it hard to clean, and some owners report units sticking in preheat.
At $699 it costs about what it has averaged for three months, and the $999 list price on the card is not a guide. It sold for about $424 over Thanksgiving weekend last year.
Pros
- +Smoke flavor reaches right through a brisket
- +Filtration keeps smoke out of the room
- +Fits on a kitchen counter
- +Useful companion app
Cons
- −Confusing controls
- −Hard to clean
- −Heavy at about 45 lb
- −Milder flavor than an outdoor smoker
- Fuel
- Electric with wood pellets
- Heat control
- Digital thermostat
- App control
- Yes
- Best for
- Apartments
Price checked on Amazon Oct 27, 2026, 12:17 PM ET.
How to choose a smoker this Black Friday
Choose the fuel by how hands-on you want to be. Electric and pellet smokers hold a set temperature for you; charcoal bullets like the Weber Smokey Mountain need vent adjustments but give the deepest bark. Offset smokers, which none of our Picks are, need a split of wood every 30 to 45 minutes, so they suit people who enjoy tending a fire.
Size it for your usual crowd, not your biggest party. The Ninja Woodfire feeds four to six people, and the 18-inch Smokey Mountain is tight for a whole brisket. The Masterbuilt 30-inch, Gravity Series 600 and Traeger Ironwood each offer 600 to 710 sq in, plenty for most families.
Plan for power and fuel. Pellet, electric and gravity-fed smokers all need a power outlet, while a charcoal bullet needs only charcoal and wood. Check your lease or HOA rules before buying for a balcony.
Ignore the list price. Several cards on this page show list prices these smokers have not sold near in months. Judge a deal against the 90-day average and the 12-month low we quote in each Pick; several of these were cheaper in May, July or last November than they are now.
Leave time to build and test it before the holidays. Large smokers take 60 to 120 minutes to assemble. Do a test cook soon after delivery, while you are still inside Amazon's return window.
How we chose these smoker deals
Every deal on this page was selected and checked by Ed Hollinghurst. We start from products with a strong track record in independent reviews and owner feedback, then compare the current Black Friday price against the product's typical selling price over the past months, not just the inflated list price. A deal only makes the cut if the product is genuinely good and the discount is real.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Commissions never influence which products we pick or how we rank them. Read our full affiliate disclosure.